Doctors accused of ‘COVID denial’ drop lawsuit against top health official

A Tel Aviv court docket dismissed Sunday a defamation swimsuit towards a senior Well being Ministry official who known as a gaggle of docs “COVID deniers.”

Dr. Sharon Alroy Preis, head of public well being providers on the Well being Ministry, was being sued for NIS 150,000 ($47,000) by 4 senior docs who’ve been publicly against sure measures taken by the ministry to curb the coronavirus pandemic.

“The pinnacle of public well being providers known as me a ‘coronavirus denier, antivaxxer’ for no purpose and with none foundation,” Dr. Amir Shachar, one of many plaintiffs, instructed Kan public radio.

“I disagree with authorities coverage, however I don’t deny the coronavirus nor do I oppose vaccines,” he stated.

The 4 docs took half in a documentary titled “And What If the Entire World Is Fallacious.” Launched initially of the yr, the movie criticized the earlier authorities, led by Benjamin Netanyahu, for its dealing with of the third wave of infections, and specifically for ordering the nation into lockdown.


Alroy-Preis responded to the video on the time by saying those that participated in it are “coronavirus deniers and antivaxxers” who had been making an attempt to disrupt public religion within the well being system. Her remarks prompted the docs to sue her.

The Tel Aviv Justice of the Peace’s Courtroom judges advisable the 4 docs not pursue the case additional, writing that “the court docket has no selection however to specific hope that the discourse between the professionals in control of the struggle towards the coronavirus can be skilled, matter-of-fact, and respectful.”

Shachar stated he and the opposite three docs accepted the court docket’s advice and withdrew the swimsuit.

The Well being Ministry praised the court docket’s dismissal in a press release revealed Sunday. “Dr. Sharon Alroy-Preis will proceed to behave with willpower and with a public mission to keep up public well being, to conduct pragmatic {and professional} dialogue within the applicable boards, to advertise data geared toward rising public belief, with out being deterred by defamation and threats,” the ministry stated.


Alroy-Preis arrived at Sunday’s listening to intently escorted by a safety guard. Armed cops had been additionally deployed on the street when her automobile arrived, defending her as she left the automobile and entered the courthouse, after deaths threats had been made towards her, blamed on anti-vaccine activists.

Well being Ministry Director-Basic Nachman Ash stated that the hounding of the pinnacle of public well being on the ministry “must be condemned and motion should taken towards it.” He instructed Radio 103FM that he hoped police would catch the culprits.

Ash stated he had spoken to Alroy-Preis the evening earlier than, and that although she is having a “arduous time,” she has no intention of giving up her place.

Dr. Sharon Alroy-Preis (proper), head of public well being providers on the Well being Ministry, at a press convention in Jerusalem on August 29, 2021, alongside Nachman Ash, director-general of the Well being Ministry. (Olivier Fitoussi/Flash90)

Ash revealed he was additionally getting threats however that they’re “a lot much less” substantial than these leveled at Alroy-Preis. “I don’t really feel that I’m at risk,” he stated.

Ash stated these behind the threats are members of a gaggle that opposes vaccination, particularly the vaccination of youngsters. Their menacing method, he stated, was “irrational,” as a result of they certainly couldn’t imagine that forcing a well being official to vary their place would cease the nation’s vaccination drive.

Israel, which already affords a three-dose vaccination routine for ages 12 and over, is poised to start inoculating kids aged 5-11 following final week’s approval by the US Meals and Drug Administration of the Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine for that age group.


Israelis protest towards the federal government’s vaccination and Inexperienced Move insurance policies, in Tel Aviv, on October 30, 2021. (Tomer Neuberg/Flash90)

The Israel Police and Well being Ministry confirmed Saturday that Alroy-Preis had been given a full-time safety element as a result of threats towards her.

Different well being consultants are afraid of giving media interviews relating to COVID-19 vaccines as a result of concrete threats posed by antivaxxer activists, Prof. Gili Regev-Yochay, the director of Sheba Medical Middle’s Infectious Illness Epidemiology Unit, instructed the Ynet information web site.

“It begins with incitement and ends method worse. We already had a chief minister who was murdered,” Regev-Yochay stated, referring to the 1995 assassination of Yitzhak Rabin by a right-wing extremist.

“They name me a Nazi, a ‘youngster poisoner,’ these kinds of issues, primarily surrounding the vaccines. It isn’t akin to what Sharon goes via. I feel it’s surprising and may’t go unanswered,” she stated.

Prof. Gili Regev-Yochay, director of the Infectious Illness Epidemiology Unit at Sheba Medical Middle (YouTube screenshot)

“The threats towards Sharon Alroy-Preis are regarding,” Regev-Yochay added.

Alroy-Preis, one of many authorities’s high COVID-19 advisers, has confronted threats and assaults for months. She has been a specific goal of anti-vaccine activists and people who chafe towards the federal government’s pandemic restrictions.

In August, she revealed that she had been given a panic button by authorities to alert police of any potential hazard, following continued harassment and threats by antivaxxers. Protests held exterior her residence earlier this yr included chants of “Nazi assassin” and “daughter of the satan,” whereas some in attendance wore yellow stars evaluating COVID restrictions to the Holocaust.

Coronavirus czar Salman Zarka additionally slammed the threats towards well being officers, saying Sunday that the general public’s angle towards the outbreak was problematic.

Coronavirus czar Prof. Salman Zarka attends a press convention concerning the coronavirus, in Jerusalem, on August 29, 2021. (Olivier Fitoussi/Flash90)

“You possibly can’t management a pandemic whereas underneath risk,” Zarka instructed Military Radio. “This isn’t only a well being drawback, however a national drawback.

“In a democratic nation, the place senior well being care officers have been working for 2 years to avoid wasting us from the hazard of the coronavirus, Dr. Alroy-Preis must stroll round with a safety guard? That’s unthinkable,” Zarka fumed.

Facebook Comments Box

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Back to top button